I read it all before you did, lol. I’ve never claimed anything about the ACTUAL origin of the singularity only pointed to the fact that others have. I’ve read plenty of Hawking and Penrose in fact. If you read the text and subtext you’ll have to admit how much uncertainty is baked in. Is it related to atheism? It still creates a universe from a “mystery entity” or an infinite number of them. You decide. I’m doubting people’s ability to comprehend counter arguments more and more. Before you school me you better read about Kant’s Antinomies and Gödel’s Incompleteness Theorem. I’m giving you a free lesson in philosophy, not logic nor semantics nor sophistry. I merely show not only what you don’t know but what you can’t know. It’s like if a bacterium wanted to learn Relativity. I’m married to an atheist so it’s not unfamiliar territory to me.